A white anatomical skull model seen from the side on a black background
Photo: Anne Nygård / Unsplash

Key takeaways

  • A subspinal Le Fort I osteotomy passes just below the anterior nasal spine, so the spine, the front of the septum and nearby tissue stay undisturbed while the tooth-bearing jaw moves.
  • Most comparisons found somewhat less widening of the nasal base; results for the tip and the nasolabial angle are mixed.
  • The evidence is thin: technique notes and retrospective series, and no randomised trial.
  • The nose can still change, because the sides of the nose opening move with the jaw.
  • It suits mainly forward and upward moves of a one-piece jaw, and needs room between the spine and the front tooth roots.

If you are planning upper jaw or double jaw surgery and wonder whether a "subspinal" cut protects the nose, this guide is for you. In short: it can reduce some changes, mainly widening of the nasal base, but it does not prevent them and does not suit every jaw. Op. Dr. Mehmet Cömert, an Istanbul plastic surgeon, plans jaw surgery together with the nose, lips and chin; the full operation is described on our double jaw surgery page.

Where a subspinal Le Fort I osteotomy cuts, and what stays attached

In brief: In a conventional Le Fort I, the anterior nasal spine moves with the upper jaw. In a subspinal design, the front of the cut dips just below the spine, often as a small V, so the spine, the front of the septum and the tissue around it stay in place.

The Le Fort I osteotomy is the standard way to move the upper jaw. Its cut runs from the edge of the nose opening, the piriform rim, towards the back of the jaw, above the tooth roots. In the subspinal version only the front changes: it passes beneath the spine. A Tokyo team describes a V-shaped cut at the base of the spine that keeps the muscle origins around the nose in place (Tomomatsu and colleagues, 2025); an earlier technique note used a horizontal cut below the spine (Díaz-González and González-García, 2007).

Why the anterior nasal spine matters to the nose and upper lip

In brief: The anterior nasal spine is a small point of bone at the front of the nasal floor, below the columella, and the septum rests on it. With a conventional cut, a forward or upward move takes the spine along, and it can push on the septum and lip.

In the textbook Facial Aesthetics (Naini, 2025), an overly prominent spine pushes the septum upwards, so the upper lip looks short and the angle between columella and lip opens. The same book links forward or upward jaw movement to a wider nasal base.

A subspinal cut stops the spine from pushing on the septum, but the edges of the nose opening still move forward and press the tissue beside the nostrils outwards. In a matched comparison, Mommaerts and colleagues (2000) concluded that those edges, not the spine, drove the increase in tip projection.

Conventional, trimmed or subspinal: the three approaches compared

In brief: The spine can move with the jaw unchanged, be trimmed or used to anchor the septum, or be left in place by cutting beneath it. The table compares what stays attached, which movements each suits, the reported effect on the nose and the limits.
Conventional Le Fort IConventional cut plus spine trimming or reattachmentSubspinal design
What stays attachedNothing at the front: the spine moves, the septum is separated, nasal base tissue is liftedAs conventional; the spine is reduced, or the septum is stitched back to it through a small drill holeThe spine, the front of the septum and the tissue around the spine
Movements it suitsEvery direction, one-piece or multi-pieceForward and upward moves in which the spine would push on the nose or lipMainly forward and upward moves of a one-piece jaw
Reported effect on the nasal baseWidening and an upturned tip are common, more so with larger movesIn one comparison, widening fell between the other two approachesLess widening in several comparisons; mixed results for the tip and the nasolabial angle
LimitsRelies on soft tissue steps such as the alar cinch, whose effect on the nose is modestHow much to remove is a judgement; a randomised trial is registered (Sezavar, 2024) but unpublishedNeeds room above the front tooth roots; small retrospective studies; the sides of the nose opening still move

The table draws mainly on a comparison of all three approaches in 90 patients (Gil and colleagues, 2022) and on the Tokyo series, in which the septal cartilage was tied through a hole in the spine; a 2025 meta-analysis found Le Fort I can increase septal deviation (Yousefi-Koma and colleagues, 2025). The alar cinch is covered in our article on nose widening after jaw surgery.

What the studies show, and how strong the evidence is

In brief: Most comparisons found slightly less widening of the nasal base with a subspinal cut, while results for the tip and the nasolabial angle disagree. The evidence consists of technique notes and retrospective series, and we found no randomised trial of subspinal against conventional cuts.

Width. In the first comparison, a small subspinal group, closed without a cinch or V-Y closure, had a narrower nasal base at six months than a conventional group that had both, but the gap shrank later (Mommaerts and colleagues, 1997). Studies of 39 and 90 patients found less widening with the subspinal cut (Yamashita and colleagues, 2020; Gil, 2022); a cohort of 96 found less at the alar base only (Meira and colleagues, 2025). In the largest series, 276 patients, movement predicted width and the cut did not (Tomomatsu, 2025).

Tip and angle. Two comparisons found no difference in tip projection (Mommaerts, 2000; Yamashita, 2020); the largest series linked the absence of a subspinal cut with more upward tip rotation. The nasolabial angle did not differ in two studies (Yamashita; Meira), and one small early study saw it move in opposite directions with the two cuts (Rushinek and colleagues, 2026).

Quality. Subspinal series still recorded widening and tip rotation (Trevisiol and colleagues, 2020; Ozaki and colleagues, 2023). A systematic review describes mostly retrospective studies at high risk of bias (Paredes de Sousa Gil and colleagues, 2019), and a 2026 review confirms that Le Fort I changes nasal shape (Jain and colleagues, 2026). The fair reading: a reasonable option with modest evidence, not a way to keep the nose unchanged.

Which jaw movements the subspinal design suits

In brief: Published experience is mostly with forward and upward moves of a one-piece upper jaw, sometimes with a downward move. We found little or no data for backward moves or multi-piece jaws, so those rest on surgical judgement.
  • Forward. The most studied move; differences between the cuts were clearest with larger advancements (Rushinek, 2026). Large moves, as in jaw surgery for sleep apnea, change the nasal base whichever cut is used.
  • Upward. Strongly linked with widening (Trevisiol, 2020), and a subspinal cut does not cancel that link (Ozaki, 2023).
  • Downward. One series included forward and downward moves (Ozaki, 2023); see maxillary downgrafting.
  • Backward. No subspinal data. A setback can make the nose look more prominent whichever cut is used (Naini, 2025).
  • Rotation and multi-piece jaws. Counterclockwise rotation added widening (Trevisiol, 2020); the 2025 comparison included only one-piece jaws. A subspinal version has been used in surgical palate expansion (Michaux and colleagues, 2022).

Muscle preservation: keeping, releasing and reattaching are not opposites

In brief: A subspinal cut leaves the attachments around the spine alone, but leaving tissue undisturbed is not always the goal. A short upper lip can benefit from release, and tissue freed in a conventional cut is stitched back in a planned position.

How much tissue any Le Fort I lifts at the nasal base, and how it is put back, is covered in our article on muscle-sparing Le Fort I. A conventional cut frees the muscles at the nasal base; the subspinal design leaves those around the spine attached, though how much stays depends on the incision and the rest of the cut. The real choices are the amount freed and the position in which it is fixed again. Freeing is not always unwanted: in a short upper lip, some release can be useful.

This fits the 2025 cohort, which found more upper lip lengthening after conventional cuts (Meira, 2025). For a short lip, release can be part of the plan; for a normal or long lip, keeping or carefully reattaching tissue matters more. Closure steps such as V-Y closure mainly change how closely the lip follows the bone (Khamashta-Ledezma and Naini, 2014). The alar cinch is routinely paired with either cut in the published series, yet how much it holds is disputed: a 2019 systematic review found little effect at six months or later (Paredes de Sousa Gil, 2019), and cinch variants performed alike in pooled randomised trials (Yang and colleagues, 2023).

Limits and risks of a subspinal cut

In brief: The main limit is space. The cut passes between the spine and the roots of the upper front teeth, which can be harmed if they sit close. Otherwise the risks are those of any Le Fort I, and the nose can still change.
  • Tooth roots. Surgeons using the design advise caution when the incisor roots are close to the spine, because the cut may harm the tooth pulp (Tomomatsu, 2025).
  • General Le Fort I risks. In a prospective series of 1,000 patients, complications were uncommon in healthy patients and included septal deviation, poor bone healing, bleeding, infection and reduced blood supply to gum and bone, the last more likely with large moves and segmented jaws (Kramer and colleagues, 2004). Our bimax surgery guide lists the rest.

Who the subspinal design may not suit, and the alternatives

In brief: It is a poor fit when the front tooth roots are close to the spine, when a short upper lip should lengthen, when more support at the nasal base is the aim, and often after an earlier Le Fort I.
  • Front tooth roots close to the spine on the CT scan.
  • A short upper lip that should lengthen.
  • A flat area beside the nasal base from a retruded upper jaw, where the aim is more support and the textbook describes a higher-level cut instead (Naini, 2025).
  • A previous Le Fort I, where the old cut shapes the options:

“To minimize risks, we plan to perform the upper jaw osteotomy along the same line used in the previous surgery, which helps avoid unnecessary complications in that area.”

Dr. Mehmet Cömert, from a patient consultation

Alternatives. The usual alternative is a conventional cut with spine trimming, septal reattachment and a cinch. A base that still widens can be narrowed later (Naini, 2025), and a nose needing reshaping in its own right is often better served by a planned rhinoplasty some months after the jaw has settled, decided case by case; see the nose after jaw surgery: Dr. Cömert answers.

How the choice of cut is made

In brief: The cut is a planning decision, not a fixed technique. Dr. Cömert plans upper jaw movements on a full CT scan and transfers them to surgery with custom cutting guides and plates, so the cut is planned before the operation.

Photographs cannot show where the spine sits relative to the tooth roots, so Dr. Cömert asks for a full CT, not a cephalometric X-ray, before deciding on any jaw cut. Whether a subspinal design fits is decided case by case, when keeping the nasal base unchanged matters and the anatomy allows it. The questions that decide it:

  1. Which way, and how far, will the front of the jaw move?
  2. Is there room between the spine and the front tooth roots?
  3. How wide is the nasal base now? In the largest series, narrower noses widened more (Tomomatsu, 2025).
  4. How long is the upper lip, and how much tooth shows at rest?
  5. Is the septum straight, and does the nose need surgery of its own?

You see the plan before anything is made; see also our double jaw surgery answers.

Next step: send your photos and scans

In brief: Start with an assessment, not a choice of cut. Send photographs and any scans you already have through the online assessment; a full CT of the whole face and jaws comes later, for planning. Dr. Cömert reviews every jaw case personally and replies with his own view.
  • front and side photographs with the face relaxed;
  • a smiling photograph showing your teeth, and one at rest with the lips slightly apart;
  • your bite in full closure, photographed from the front and both sides;
  • whatever CT or intraoral scans you already have: photos and existing scans are enough to start, a full-face-and-jaw CT is needed before a cut is chosen, and a CBCT limited to the teeth will not do;
  • notes from earlier nose or jaw surgery, and any breathing problems.

He will tell you whether jaw surgery suits you, which movement it would involve and how the nose would be protected.

Prepared by the practice of Op. Dr. Mehmet Cömert, European Board-certified (FEBOPRAS) plastic, aesthetic and reconstructive surgeon, Istanbul. Quotations are from Dr. Cömert's own patient consultations. Sources are listed below. Last updated 20 November 2026. This article is general information and does not replace a personal medical assessment.